State report card gives wide range of grades to county schools

Published 11:12 am Tuesday, December 26, 2023

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

By Buzz Trexler
Star Correspondent
The Tennessee Department of Education released its grades for individual schools statewide on Thursday and while the state report is not intended for a systemwide grade, when taken on average Carter County schools netted a “C” – 3.1 on a 5-point scale.

Carter County Schools Director Brandon Carpenter did not respond to our request for comment.

The state graded the individual Carter County schools as follows:

Subscribe to our free email newsletter

Get the latest news sent to your inbox

— Happy Valley Elementary, B, 4.3;

— Little Milligan, B, 4;

— Valley Forge Elementary, B, 4;

— Happy Valley Middle School, B, 3.9;

— Cloudland Elementary School, B, 3.7;

— Hunter Elementary, B, 3.7;

— Central Elementary, C, 3.3;

— Unaka High School, C, 3.2;

— Hampton High School, C, 2.9;

— Cloudland High School, C, 2.8;

— Unaka Elementary, C, 2.8;

— Keenburg Elementary, C, 2.7

— Happy Valley High School, D, 2.4;

— Hampton Elementary, D, 2.2; and

— Carter County Online Academy, D, 1.5;

Siam Learning Center was deemed ineligible for a letter grade.

In 2016, the General Assembly passed a law requiring every school to receive a letter grade: A, B, C, D, or F. The legislature mandated that achievement and growth be used in determining the grade, while the Department of Education was given leeway to determine other factors. Eventually, the grading system included student achievement as measured by the Tennessee Comprehensive Assessment Program (TCAP) test; student academic growth by way of all students; student academic growth of the school’s highest-need students, those who rank among the bottom 25 percent based on achievements; and high schools are graded on college and career readiness, “based on how many graduating students succeed on measures like the ACT, college credit exams or opportunities, industry credentials, and military readiness.”

“School letter grades will provide Tennessee families with a clear rating system that gives them a snapshot of how their child’s school is performing,” Lizzette Reynolds, commissioner of education, said in a release prepared for school systems and posted on the state’s website. “No matter what your school’s letter grade is, everyone can play a role in supporting the success of our students and the success of our schools by engaging with your local school communities and joining the conversation.”

Knox County educator and Tennessee Education Association President Tanya T. Coats said in a release, “Tennessee already has school accountability in its comprehensive online report card system that is easily understood. Every Tennessee school lists achievement and growth on standardized tests, including subgroups like English Language Learners and students with disabilities. The system also reports other factors like absenteeism, graduation rates and college and career readiness among others – indicators not reflected in a single letter grade.

“It is insulting to students, parents, educators and communities to label our schools with a single letter grade weighted heavily on a flawed high-stakes standardized test,” Coats said. “It is impossible to capture the hard work of Tennessee students and educators with such a simplistic rating.”

For more details on an individual school’s grade, go online to the A-F Letter Grade Dashboard at